Skip to content
Selling in Lancaster Park
Lancaster Park is a small neighborhood of brick streets and 1920s houses on Lake Lancaster, two miles south of downtown Orlando, entered through gates the residents maintain themselves. It turned a hundred years old in 2025. Selling here is mostly a matter of getting a buyer to understand how unusual that combination is inside a city this size.
The neighborhood is bordered by Lake Lancaster on the north and west, East Kaley Street on the south, and South Fern Creek Avenue on the east. That is all of it. Two hundred and forty-four lots were platted here in the 1920s, and the boundaries have not moved since.
A buyer who has been shopping South Orlando has probably seen a lot of houses of roughly this vintage. What they have not seen is many streets that still look like this, and the job of a Lancaster Park listing is to make the difference legible rather than assume it announces itself in photographs.
What Happened Here in 1925
In 1920 this was farmland on early maps, well outside the city, and the whole property was offered for sale that year for $12,000.
Then Florida happened. On February 4, 1925, the Orlando Morning Sentinel reported that representatives of a Chicago syndicate had arrived in town the previous day and bought $150,000 of property on Lake Lancaster. The buyer was the Sias-Shepherd-Wright Investment Company, which brought in the designer and builder Alva W. McDonald and developed the neighborhood across that year.
Lots went on sale in March 1926. That September the company held open houses on the first four finished model homes, advertised as “the Homes Artistic,” and the newspapers reported that three thousand people came out in the rain to walk through them. They were sold as old-world charming and thoroughly modern at once: running water, paved streets, sidewalks, curbs, electricity, heaters, and, in those first four houses, electric refrigeration units installed by Johnson Electric.
In 1928 the Cousins Investment Company of Brooklyn bought the subdivision for $450,000, with its 244 lots and close to a mile of Lake Lancaster frontage.
Two houses were already standing before any of that started. One was built in 1901 as a farmhouse, and one in 1910 from a kit sold by Sears, Roebuck and Company. Both are still here.
The Oldest House Was Not Built Here
The oldest house in the neighborhood arrived in one piece and then in many.
It was built downtown in 1891 by one of Orlando’s earliest physicians and stood for fifty years at East Jackson Street and Main Street, which is now Magnolia Avenue. In 1941, Marcellus J. Moss and his wife Mary had it dismantled and moved out to Lancaster Park. The Moss family started the neighborhood holiday party, which has carried on in one form or another ever since.
That is the kind of thing that seems like local color until you watch a buyer hear it. Continuity is the product here, and specific stories are how it gets communicated. Orange County property records show at least one house built in the neighborhood in every decade since the 1920s, which means this has never been a place that stalled and got rediscovered. It has just kept going.
The Brick Streets and the Gates
The original brick streets are still down, and they are not a decorative touch added later.
Roughly eight percent of Orlando’s streets are brick, about 57 miles of them, and the city runs an ongoing brick street rehabilitation program that relays the brick after utility work rather than patching over it. Brick also drains better than asphalt, which is why the restoration work is often paired with stormwater upgrades. If a buyer asks whether the streets are a maintenance problem waiting to happen, the honest answer is that the city treats them as infrastructure worth keeping.
The gates at the entrance were built in the mid to late 1920s. A photograph from 1934 shows them standing with nothing behind them but trees, the lake and the brick. The residents maintain those gates themselves, which tells a prospective buyer more about how this neighborhood operates than any description of the community could.
Old Neighborhood, No Design Review
This is the point most often gotten wrong, in both directions, and it is worth being exact about.
Lancaster Park is not one of the City of Orlando’s designated local historic districts. Lake Cherokee, Lake Copeland, Lake Eola Heights, Lake Lawsona and Colonialtown South are; Lancaster Park is not. There is no historic preservation board review sitting between an owner here and a window replacement.
Buyers assume the opposite, and the assumption cuts both ways. Some walk away from a hundred-year-old streetscape because they think they will need approval to change a door. Others assume the character is protected by ordinance and will therefore last forever. Neither is right. What holds this neighborhood together is a century of owners choosing to, plus a set of gates that people pay to keep up out of their own pockets.
For your listing that is genuinely useful information, and it should be stated plainly rather than left for a buyer’s agent to guess at. Confirm the current status for your own parcel before you rely on it, since designations can change, but do not let a buyer talk themselves out of the house over a restriction that does not exist.
The Lake and the Park
Lake Lancaster wraps the neighborhood on two sides, which is why the streets curve the way they do and why the lots on the water were the ones marketed first in 1926.
Lake Lancaster Park at 1550 Briercliff Drive is a city park, open six in the morning until eleven at night. Set expectations accurately: the city lists it as open space rather than a facility, so it is a place to walk to and sit by the water, not a recreation complex. Wadeview Park over on East Harding Street is the one with the pavilions, playgrounds and exercise trail, and Wadeview Pool is a few minutes further.
If your home has frontage or a water view, measure it and say so. If it does not, give the walking distance to the lake, which for most of this neighborhood is short enough to be a real amenity rather than a stretch.
Where It Sits
Two miles from downtown Orlando, immediately north of Boone High School on East Kaley Street, and a few minutes from the Orlando Health campus and the SoDo corridor on South Orange Avenue for shopping and errands.
That location does specific work for specific buyers. A physician or nurse at the Orlando Health campus can live in a 1926 house on a brick street and still be minutes from a shift. A downtown professional gets a genuine neighborhood instead of a building. Both of those are worth naming in the listing with the actual distances attached, because “close to downtown” is what every listing south of the 408 already says.
Schools
Boone High School is on East Kaley Street at the neighborhood’s southern edge, and Blankner School, the K-8 on South Mills Avenue, is the other name that comes up constantly here.
Confirm the assignment for your exact address rather than repeating what the neighborhood generally believes. Orange County assigns by address and redraws boundaries periodically. The district’s school locator is the authority, and quoting it exactly is worth more to a buyer than a confident generalization that later turns out to be wrong.
What This Means for Your Listing
The mistake to avoid here is selling a Lancaster Park house on its square footage and its finishes. There is always something bigger and newer available a short drive away, and on those terms this neighborhood does not win.
What it has instead is unrepeatable: brick streets that are still brick, gates from the 1920s that neighbors keep up, a lake on two sides, a hundred-year run with no interruption, and a location two miles from downtown and minutes from the hospital campus. A buyer standing in the yard can verify every one of those in an afternoon. Give them the specifics, including the honest ones about what is and is not regulated, and the comparison stops being about square footage.
Local Orlando Seller Representation
Scott and I will walk your street with you, tell you plainly what we would address and what we would leave alone, and give you a number we can support with what has actually closed nearby. No obligation, and no listing presentation unless you ask for one.
Neighboring areas have their own pages: Delaney Park, SoDo and Lake Como.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should a Lancaster Park listing emphasize?
The things that cannot be reproduced: original brick streets, the 1920s entrance gates the neighborhood maintains itself, Lake Lancaster on two sides, and a two-mile distance to downtown with the Orlando Health campus in between. Then the specific history of your own house, which in this neighborhood is usually documented and usually interesting.
Is Lancaster Park a historic district? Will a buyer face design review?
It is not one of the City of Orlando’s designated local historic districts, so there is no preservation board review of ordinary changes. Buyers frequently assume otherwise and it costs sellers showings. State it accurately, and confirm the current status for your parcel before relying on it.
Are the brick streets a liability?
They are city infrastructure, and the city runs a rehabilitation program that relays brick after utility work rather than paving over it. Brick also handles run-off better than asphalt, which is why restoration is often paired with stormwater work. Treat it as a feature and answer the question directly if a buyer raises it.
My house is a hundred years old. How much should I update before listing?
Less than you would in a newer neighborhood, and more selectively. The buyer who wants this street usually wants the house to read its age. Systems, roof and anything that will show up in an inspection are worth attention. Erasing the original character to look like new construction is how sellers here spend money and lose their best buyer at the same time.
Does the neighborhood have an HOA?
Confirm the specifics for your own property before answering a buyer, because what governs a hundred-year-old subdivision is often a mix of old recorded restrictions and a voluntary neighborhood association rather than a modern mandatory HOA. Buyers ask about dues, obligations and what the association actually controls, so have the documents in hand rather than an impression.
